I had written a post back in early 2017 talking about what I thought Trump’s election was going to lead to in the US and it turns out I was surprisingly prescient. Much of what I predicted came to be, certainly in terms of corruption. The levels of self-dealing and public corruption going on now in Trump’s second term is orders of magnitude worse than anything that has ever happened before in the entire history of the United States. But that is a tale for another time.
It turns out that in March 2024 some random guy (from California, based on his IP address) posted a comment on that post that I never noticed until a few weeks ago. I suppose he felt the urge to say something because he was frustrated with Joe Biden. That is certainly the impression he gives. Anyway, here’s what he said:
do you think you were wrong now after seeing Biden in office? Are you a Trump supporter now? I understand you were upset and probably looking at thing differently but by now you had to have changed your mind about everything the bad man said and turns out he was right about everything? Winston Churchill once said “Anyone who was not a liberal at 20 years of age had no heart, while anyone who was still a liberal at 40 had no head.”
Well, random person who apparently has poor judgment (he is apparently a Trump supporter, after all), you know what? Your response kind of amused me, possibly because for some reason you thought that I would agree with you. Right.
For whatever reason, I felt compelled to respond to this old comment (the guy had to post an email address to post a comment, and I guess he didn’t have the presence of mind to post a fake one). So I did. Mind you, I wrote this in late October, before the results of the 2026 midterm elections, but nevertheless, I think it struck just the right tone.
Dear [name redacted to protect the dumb],
While going through the old backlog of WordPress comments that we had on our blog, I found a comment that you had left for some unknown reason, since we don’t know you at all and as far as I know, you don’t know us either. Nevertheless, you felt the need to leave a comment on our blog, named The Books Are Taking Over. Specifically, you left a comment on my blog post that I wrote WAY back in January 2017 about the election of Donald Trump as president of the United States. My post was titled “Lily Tomlin was right. No matter how cynical you get, it’s impossible to keep up.” You posted your comment years later, on March 17, 2024, I guess because the spirit moved you to do so in an election year.
Forever preserved for posterity, here it is unchanged as you originally posted it:
do you think you were wrong now after seeing Biden in office? Are you a Trump supporter now? I understand you were upset and probably looking at thing differently but by now you had to have changed your mind about everything the bad man said and turns out he was right about everything? Winston Churchill once said “Anyone who was not a liberal at 20 years of age had no heart, while anyone who was still a liberal at 40 had no head.”
My dude, where do I begin.
First, I am a historian, and have been for 35 years or so. I am pretty damn sure that Winston Churchill never, ever uttered the simplistic, trite, and artless horseshit you attributed to him. For one thing, like myself, Churchill was conservative as a young man and became more liberal as he got older. For another, there is no date, location, or context attributed to it, and that’s always a bad sign for any quote. Lastly, don’t take my word for it. Both the International Churchill Society and Richard M. Langworth (the preeminent expert on Churchill quotes, since he wrote at least five books about Churchill quotes) believe that particular quote was NEVER said by Churchill, and they would know.
https://winstonchurchill.org/resources/quotes/quotes-falsely-attributed
https://richardlangworth.com/category/winston-s-churchill/fake-quotes
Second, I don’t know if you are able to do any critical thinking whatsoever (and sadly, since you were a Trump supporter two years ago, it’s not likely), but I am curious about whether YOUR perspective on Trump has changed. Here is what I wrote then, almost ten years ago:
It should be obvious by now that Donald Trump has no impulse control, no real intellectual curiosity, and no thought for anything or anyone else but himself. He is, as I once described him way back in the 1980’s, “the physical embodiment of narcissism and greed”. He does not see the office of the President as public service, as a responsibility that he has been entrusted with by the American people. He sees it as a way to boost his brand. [I think he also saw it as a way to stay out of prison, but I digress.] Why do you think he does not care one whit about all of his conflicts of interest? Because they are not a bug of his Presidency, they are a feature. He has surrounded himself with family and others that have no qualifications for any sort of high office, but are loyal to him, at least for the moment. And apparently, he regards that loyalty as the only thing that matters. I think that is why you see so many of his sycophants tying themselves into knots on television, trying to rationalize his behaviors to the world. But there is no way to rationalize it because it has no real logic, aside from the preservation of the ego and fortune of one man.
We have handed over our country to a powerful man who lives moment to moment, with no thought of anyone but himself, and who has such a thin skin that he literally cannot let any insult go unchallenged.
I think a lot of people still do not fully understand what that means.
Quite possibly, it means that we are almost certainly on the verge of experiencing the most corrupt and scandal-ridden administration that this country has ever seen. One that will make the administrations of Warren G. Harding and Ulysses S. Grant look like unambitious underachievers. And frankly that is probably the best outcome we can expect.
At the worst, our country may truly be on the verge of something so unpredictable, and unforeseen, that we as a society will find ourselves struggling to deal with it, and before we truly understand what is happening it may spiral completely out of control.
I cannot think of any time I have ever wished I was more wrong. I hope it is so.
Sadly, in terms of corruption, I was 100% correct. And in terms of what he has done and is doing to our alliances, our economy, our national reputation, our government departments, and our military power, I was also correct. He has been an absolute wrecking ball. Are you thrilled that gasoline, heating oil, and diesel fuel prices are going through the roof? Are you excited that we are involved in a war with Iran that he said would be quick and he has no fucking idea how to get us out of it? Both he and the Republican-controlled Congress are either unable or unwilling to do anything that actually solves real problems for people like you and me. Do you get that? Has it sunk in yet? Not even the Epstein files could convince you that the man is both vile and evil?
Well, I don’t want to waste your time or mine if you are still in the Trump cult, because then of course nothing I say will convince you anyway. But honestly, I do pity you on some level. But then I remember that people like you enabled him and everything he and his minions have done and that all my nieces and nephews now have to grow up in a world that you helped him make much worse. So frankly, you should probably roast in hell, and who knows, you may end up there anyway. But if you have a handful of brain cells still working and a sliver of conscience left, maybe you can at least save yourself and your immortal soul by voting against Trump’s enablers on Tuesday, November 3rd.
Sincerely,
Geoff
I sent off my response early in the evening. Much to my surprise, I got a response later that very night. Much to my non-surprise, he did not have a thoughtful or articulate response to my email or any of my questions.
Who the fuck are you faggot? Go fuck yourself
Yes, my new Internet pen pal could not even be bothered to expend the effort to give me proper punctuation, much less answer any of my inquiries. What a shame. Such a disappointment.
Anyway, just wanted to share that with you all. And you earned yourself an ENTIRE BLOG POST, Mr. Random Internet Troll. Somehow, I think this may just be one of the more significant accomplishments in your life in recent years. If I had more time I would send you a certificate or something you could print out. But it’s late on Friday and I have had a long week, so you are just going to have to console yourself with something else, like smoking meth or posting angry Facebook posts or whatever you do for intellectual stimulation. You do you, my angry friend.
-Geoff